Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
12 Pie
Sun Dried Tomato Bread
Soda
Cheesecake
About
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pleasant Ridge
If you’re hunting for authentic flavors and a vibrant atmosphere in Cincinnati, look no further than Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pleasant Ridge. Located at 6099 Montgomery Rd, this pizzeria is quickly becoming a beloved spot for both locals and visitors alike. With an inviting vibe and a rooftop that offers stunning views of Pleasant Ridge, it’s a great place to relax after a long day.
At the heart of the menu lies an impressive selection of well-crafted dishes. The calzones are a must-try—these half moon turnovers are generously stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella, allowing you to customize with your choice of toppings for a hearty meal. For those craving classic comfort, the Al Pacino meatball sub steals the show. This extra-large sandwich, filled with the best meatballs and a signature marinara sauce, is served on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette. Trust me, you won't want to share this indulgent treat!
And let’s not overlook the sides. The cheese bread, brushed with garlic butter and piled high with mozzarella, is perfect for sharing—if you’re feeling generous. Or opt for the pesto bread, made with housemade pesto and baked to a golden perfection. Each bite is a delightful experience that reflects the quality and care put into every dish.
Beyond the food, the ambiance at Goodfellas Pizzeria is infectious. From the welcoming staff to the relaxed rooftop view, every visit feels special. Customers rave about the dedicated team, with shoutouts to stars like Chris and Chelsea, who elevate the dining experience with their warm hospitality. Whether you’re enjoying an old-fashioned crafted by Max or soaking in the atmosphere with a group of friends, it’s clear that Goodfellas is dedicated to making every moment memorable.
Testimonials from patrons speak volumes, with one guest stating how Goodfellas changed their perspective on pizza and service. It’s this ethos of excellence, combined with mouthwatering cuisine, that sets Goodfellas Pizzeria apart as a true culinary gem in the heart of Cincinnati. Be sure to visit for a taste of this extraordinary experience!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ It has been a week now being in Cincinnati, after searching the web looking for dinner spots I came across this place, came in looking for a pizza and left with a changed perspective on the pizza and service industry. Everybody part of the staff was super easy going and made the experience smooth, especially Chris at the front hooked me and my buddy up with some great eats and even got us top floor access to the rooftop. Definitely will be coming back, from his hospitality to the food, this place is doing it right! ”
“ This is the best bar in Montgomery road and the pizza is a nice addition ! The seasonal drink menus are a hit and Wednedays with the specials on old fashions are my personal favorites. See Dave with the pizza and Max with the drinks . This will lead to a great experience . The rooftop that views pleasant ridge is the icing in the cake . No fluff just good vibes and good pizza !! ”
“ Goodfellas is our favorite pizza in the area, yet this was our 1st time at this location. Pizza and cocktails were amazing as always! The staff was welcoming and friendly. Special shout out to Reese, and also to Cody, who makes a fantastic old fashioned and margarita. We especially loved the upstairs patio area, which was my favorite of the few locations we have been to. We will be back next time we are in the area for sure!! ”
“ Chelsea is a rock star!! She always takes such good care of us; makes us feel welcome and warm every time! :) ”
“ Absolutely AMAZING!! We ordered "The Naples" pizza 100/10 We also ordered the meatball sub and ill give that 7/10 , just because the pizza was SO good! We had the bartenders "surprise" us on drinks and they hit it out of the park!! We will definitely be regulars here! ”
“ Title: Meatball Sub Heaven at Goodfellas Pizzeria—Give Me 14 of Them! If you haven’t tried the Meatball Sub at Goodfellas Pizzeria, let me save you some time: Go. Right. Now. Seriously, it’s not just a sandwich—it’s an experience. Picture this: Perfectly seasoned, juicy meatballs, packed into a fresh, toasted hoagie, drenched in marinara that tastes like it’s been simmering for hours. It’s got that homemade, hearty flavor that makes you feel like you’re at Nonna’s table. Then, they hit it with a generous layer of melted mozzarella that just hugs those meatballs like they’re meant to be together. But wait—here’s where it gets next level. Smack it down with some Peroni beer, ice-cold and crisp, balancing the richness of that glorious sub. Don’t forget the ranch on the side for dipping, and top it off with fresh cracked pepper and a good sprinkle of Parmesan cheese. You’re not just eating—you’re living. Honestly, I could eat 14 of these bad boys and still want more. The combination is so spectacular that it’s almost unfair to every other sandwich out there. Goodfellas Pizzeria, you’ve got a masterpiece on your hands. If you’re in the mood for comfort food done right, do yourself a favor—get the Meatball Sub, the Peroni, and make it a good day. #FoodieLife #GoodfellasPizzeria #MeatballSubMadness ”
“ Reese can make a pie! Stopped in on the way home to Lancaster. We are pizza connoisseur’s. Flavor 10/10 Crust Crisp 10/10 New York style thin crust highly recommend ”
“ We came in 20 minutes before they closed and they didn’t have any pepperoni left. Reese Austin and Chelsea went above and beyond and offered to make a fresh one. Reese went the extra step and made us feel appreciated as customers. So I want them to know we appreciate them!!! A good restaurant is nothing without the people in it and this one definitely has the right people. Thank you guys for going the extra mile!!! ”